Columbia Benton Springs Review: The Fleece to Live In?
Columbia's soft full-zip fleece has been listed for years and is still the jacket many women wear from fall to spring. What it does well, and where a real coat wins.
Yes, for a woman who dresses in layers and wants one jacket for errands, the office and dog walks. It is soft, light and easy to layer, with two zip pockets [1]. Skip it as a winter coat: fleece lets the wind through, so it belongs under a shell, not instead of one.
By Andrew Pataleta, GiftX founder · Updated October 28, 2026 · Sources
Specs at a glance
| Fabric | 100% polyester MTR filament fleece [1] |
| Closure | Full zip [1] |
| Pockets | Two zippered hand pockets [1] |
| Neck | Collared [1] |
| Fit | Modern classic, active slim cut [1] |
| Hem | Interior drawcord [1] |
| Model number | 1372111 [1] |
| On Amazon since | February 2017 [1] |
Pros and cons
- Not windproof or water resistant
- The slim cut leaves little room for a thick sweater
- Fleece can pill after years of washing
The jacket by the front door
Every closet has one jacket that gets worn more than the rest. For many women it is a soft full-zip fleece that goes over a T-shirt on a cool morning and under a coat in January.
The Benton Springs has been on Amazon since 2017, and Columbia still sells it in a long list of colors [1]. That staying power is a good sign for a clothing gift.
It is also the kind of clothing gift that rarely misses: no tricky fit at the shoulders, no strong pattern, nothing to iron.
Soft fleece and zip pockets
The listing describes soft polyester filament fleece, a collared neck and a full zip [1]. The two side pockets zip shut, so keys and a phone stay put on a walk [1].
An interior drawcord lets her pull in the hem, and the active slim cut keeps it from looking like a sack [1].
Wind, rain and real cold
Fleece is warm in still air. In wind it loses heat fast, and in rain it soaks through.
For a woman in a cold, windy city, this is a layer, not a coat. Under a shell or a parka, it does the job of a warm sweater that never itches.
Over years of washing, fleece can pill at the cuffs and under the arms, which is normal wear rather than a fault.
Sizing it as a gift
The cut is slim, so if she likes room for a sweater underneath, a size up is the safer guess. Keep the gift receipt either way.
From this guide, it pairs with the DREAM PAIRS Women's Mid Calf Winter Snow Boots for winter walks, or the Owala FreeSip Water Bottle for weekend trails.
FAQ
Is the Columbia Benton Springs fleece warm enough for winter?
On its own, only for cool, still days. It is a light fleece, so it works best as a layer under a shell or a parka in real winter weather. On a dry fall or spring day it is enough over a long-sleeve shirt, which is why many women wear it most of the year [1]
Does the Columbia Benton Springs run small?
The listing calls the fit a modern classic with an active slim cut [1]. It sits close to the body, so size up if she layers a sweater under it. If she will wear it over a T-shirt, her usual size is the normal choice. Keep the gift receipt for an easy exchange after Christmas [1]
Is a fleece jacket a good Christmas gift for a woman?
It is one of the safer clothing gifts, because fleece is forgiving on fit and nearly everyone wears one. Pick a neutral color she already wears, check her usual size, and it becomes the jacket she grabs for errands, school runs and dog walks most of the year [1]
Featured in these guides
All product reviews · All gift guides
Sources and how we checked
- Amazon.com listing for the Columbia Women's Benton Springs Full Zip Fleece
Source check: Amazon prices and contents above were checked on October 28, 2026. We did not test these products hands-on. Picks are based on manufacturer specs, Amazon listings and the reasons people actually give these gifts.
As an Amazon Associate, GiftX earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability change, so check Amazon for the current price.